Thursday, July 22, 2010
Unit One: Passed
So my new position, which starts August 2nd, will be Assistant Coordinator for HIV Testing and Linkage to Care. That means I'll be managing grants, supervising a couple staff, possibly writing grants, as well as policies and procedures. Fun! It's so different than the previous job, I can't even really compare them, except that they're in the same center.
I'm super excited about getting to learn more about how the center runs from the inside and feeling more productive/important (although I'm also aware now that that "importance" is pretty much all about ego...hey, I'm young, I'm allowed to have an ego, right??). It certainly doesn't hurt I'm getting an increase in income. Yay!
So that is my big, boiling-over news. The other excitement (there's been quite a bit in the past couple of weeks) is a cross-country road trip I'm planning with my friend, Julie (former roommate, Julie). She's moving to LA and needed someone to drive with her and all her shit out there. I volunteered.
I'm somewhat conflicted about this trip because this was the week I was going to go to NC, but I also think it will be a rare opportunity in my life to drive cross-country, and spend some (hah, who are we kidding?? A SHIT-ton) time with my friend who's moving away, at least for now.
So those are some pretty stellar things happening. On top of that, I've launched into a whirlwind romance that I will not detail here, suffice to say it has pleasantly turned my world upside down, and I have somehow managed to continue to feel fully like myself, only maybe even more so. It's been pretty fantastic, and like some sort of chocolate icing on a cake that I'd been baking (the trips, job, new neighborhood). It kind of brings it all together.
In short--life is good. I'm trying to enjoy the brilliant part of all this, and not worry about when it will all come crashing down. But this time, I really do see that I have worked my butt off to get all this to work out, and it's great it's all happening at the same time, but it's all stuff I've really been waiting for and working towards. And now, I'm enjoying my delicious cake.
Thursday, July 8, 2010
Boredom
I have been voraciously reading it since--I'm on page 685 of 1105 (the "pages" are teeny). Wow. I did not expect to think this was so awesome. So, two of my problems with reading, apart from having trouble finding excellent books, is about comfort of being able to read, and for some reason, I do actually find the iPhone comfortable to hold. Not sure how I'd feel about the iPad. But I don't have one, so no worries. But more than that, I would always forget a book (left the most recent physical book I was reading on a bus, remember that??). But THIS book is INSIDE my phone! So whenever I have my phone, and it is not dying (which I have learned how to prevent with some simple energy-saving tips via Google), I have my book. This is awesome! I actually do think more than that, I seriously adore this book. I have fallen head over heels for Elizabeth Gilbert--I just think she's fabulous. And it's strange, because I've meant to read this book for quite some time, but it's so perfect for the place I'm in, and while it makes me really want to travel, it also makes me realize how far I've come. How much of what she's doing in the book, I've done in New York. Less the spiritual stuff, more the self-actualization and acceptance (which I think the spiritual stuff really is all about). So I am really enjoying this book, and the experience of not having to remember it, just having it with me at all times.
Other ways that the iPhone has prevented boredom/enhanced my life include solitaire, word warp (which I've found to improve my Scrabble skillz, much to my pleasant surprise), sudoku, reading the news via NY Times application or my RSS feed application, and of course the Facebook application. I would not know New York nearly as well without the help of the awesome map, and finding my way around the subway system with The Map application is much easier. I've loved being able to take pictures and immediately upload them to Facebook--it's made both the ability to take pictures with the phone and Facebook much more awesome. There are just so many amazing things that the phone, well, computer, is capable of, and it is seriously incredible that so much can be so small. I've also felt like it really has enhanced my life, as it has given me more access to podcasts of all flavors in addition to my music, and wonderful audiobooks as well. I just have used the heck out of this thing, and I adore it's capabilities.
Okay, done with the iPhone lovefest haha.
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
Incongruence
I have been frustrated before about the sociological implications of my job, and my having more social power but not any more technical power in the work place. Maybe not articulated exactly that way, but that's how I see if now. But this truly takes the cake, AND I think I didn't realize how unaligned my view of the world is with several of the folks I work with. Now, we have several Case Managers (6?), several of whom I get along quite well with, at least I think. But there are two with whom I have seen more potential for difficulty--I'll call them R and C. Both of these women fall into the categories of black women who are former drug users, have cleaned up and gotten Bachelor's degrees, and a great union job. There is one other coworker who fits into this category (we'll call her B). But for whatever reason, I have seen R and C are much more intimidated?
So I have had not really any difficulty with C (though she can be frustrating to deal with), perhaps because I have skated around her as though I could see the ice cracking already. But I felt more comfortable with R from the beginning, which I think ironically made things more dangerous. Once EMR began and everyone started asking me questions about computers ALL THE TIME (not complaining, just noting), she would call me and I would answer, "What?" because I wanted people to get to the point. Not the most professional, I realize, but actually I think it was an attempt to communicate like my coworkers (in a joking way), just the way I interpreted it. Which was not appreciated. She informed me; I have not since answered any of her phone calls or yelling out from her desk with, "What?"
Then a few months ago, all of our supervisors were gone except for a very high-up supervisor, and I made the mistake? of telling him what I wad doing. R told me that he doesn't need to be involved in our business, that we do our own thing and keep to ourselves. Which, to me, is bizarre. I come from the assumption that authority is here to protect us, to make sure everything that needs to get done, does. Which really is what all this boils down to. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
So yesterday R comes over to me and asks in a very flustered manner what we were supposed to be doing with a particular list. I had created a set of directions to do what needed to be done (which she didn't actually know), but before I told her that, I did not want her to be mad. I mean, she can be mad, but I didn't want to be talking to someone who was so flustered, even as it was not directed towards me. So I made a huge mistake. Huge. And also very preventable, had I taken two seconds to think about it, and reacted to her as a person unlike me. But no, I told her to take a breath. Bad move. Did I make that clear yet??
She told me not to talk to her "like that," to never mind and walked away. Whoops. Now, part of me really wishes I just had never said anything. But I also feel frustrated in not being able to be myself. In not being around people who are self-assured enough to shrug off my telling them to take a breath, or who can take a breath and laugh, or whatever. My intention was not to infer that she did not know how to calm herself down, but that we all need a reminder sometimes. And also that I don't talk to people who are upset. I won't. That is my limit. And I was trying to convey that in as inoffensive way as possible. But I guess it backfired.
So what I realized it that there is just a huge incongruence in how I view authority an how R does. Asking our supervisor to mediate a conversation did not help. Why did I think it would? She spent the conversation telling me she thinks I look down on her (I actually believe "us" was the word used), and that she was concerned about her job because I brought our supervisor in (though the supervisor made quite clear that she was not there in a supervisory nor disciplinary manner). Despite being I a union. Despite having done nothing wrong. Certainly nothing punishment-worthy. Despite my actually asking HER for information about what I could do differently that would help. Despite all that, she felt threatened. And like I think I'm better than her. And that I have power that she does not. And you know what? She's right. Not about my being better than her, but that I have more power. I am affluent, if not in my finances, in my vocabulary, in my demeanor, in my confidence and sense of empowerment. And that all counts for a lot, and goes to show you that poverty is about a hell of a lot more than money. It is disturbing to me that an adult reacted as she did to the entire situation, but I have to remember that she's coming from such a different world. A world where adults and other figures of authority are not to be trusted, and do not have your best intentions in mind.
I am so lucky to not be from that world. But I'm living in it right now, and talk about culture shock, in truly the most depressing way possible. It is a world of no hope, and distrust of but unavoidable reliance upon authority figures. Fear, uncertainty and doubt. This is America, dystopia-style.
Thursday, June 3, 2010
This would be my Facebook status if it weren't so long
This morning was way busy at work (yay!), and I ended up going to the pharmacy with a client to get his medications. Well, we're in the Rite Aid, and as the pharmacist is explaining that the client will actually have to pay for one of the things, and it will cost maybe $4-6, he is saying he doesn't have $5, which is pathetic but probably true (at least sort of, like, at least not $5 to spare), and this older woman at the same moment is getting her reciept while picking up her prescription, and notes that the reciept is extremely long and what a waste of paper that is (wait until she looks at the printed information that you get with EVERY REFILL. Talk about wasted paper). But I was just so struck by the contrasted concerns--my patient upset because Medicaid won't pay $5 for something, and this woman totally distressed that the Rite Aid was wasting so much paper. Perfectly New York.
It's definitely sad. And also hilariously demonstrative of how effed up our country is. How much we waste and yet, can only help people a small bit. I also should note that today alone I had two patients say they think AIDS is a conspiracy by "them" to kill black people or make money by not using the cure that he was convinced they already have developed.
Sometimes I think I'm really naive. I totally give people the benefit of the doubt; assume they are logical. But actually, most people don't understand much about the world. Probably myself included. I try and explain to people that no one is actually out to get them. They probably don't believe me. Or, worse, think I'm "them." Not that I approve of how the world is or works. But the feeling and effects of dis-empowerment is quite striking.
Sunday, May 30, 2010
SATC 2
The main takeaway for me was that it could have been so good!! There were a few scenes that were actually quite touching and insightful--into the characters, into our society. And then there was all this random shit that happened. As if the producers went (Molly's words), "You know what, folks? This movie is going to make a butt-load, no matter what it is about. So let's make a list of things that would be cool to include, and we'll draw some out of a hat and just throw those in. Wouldn't that be fun??" The most awful part was a scene where the women do karaoke together--they sing "I Am Woman," which is not upbeat nor popular in the last 30 years. And just kind of dumb. What made it most tragic was the possibility--it could have been "I Will Survive" or something. Which is awesome and empowering, maybe not the right lyrics, but really fun. I'm sure they could've thought of something else. So that was frustrating.
It was also just really obnoxiously ostentatious to a completely unnecessary degree. And Carrie was way annoying, more-so than in the show or the first movie. And just generally all the complaints were so ridiculous. Their lives are all without any financial worries, and they can't figure out ways to make their live mean something? Just kind of stupid. Anyway, I'm still glad I saw it, if only for nostalgia.
Friday, May 28, 2010
End of May
Now onto work on those things that need some shaking up! Here's to another adventurous, bewildering, scary year in my life. This one has brought a world I couldn't have imagined. One that is surprisingly stable, despite my efforts. And next year, hopefully by this time I'll be on the shores of a foreign land, relaxing with a delicious drink of some exotic kind and staring into the great abyss of the Atlantic or Pacific. Doesn't matter which. Maybe I'll be by myself. Maybe someone will have come to visit and share the celebration of a completion of 25 years...who knows. But I damn well will not be here. And really, I mean this in the most hopeful, not depressing, way--that's what keeps me going. Knowing that soon, things will be different.
Ok so I'm still bored at work. That's pretty much the end of that thought process. But I really have been doing a lot of reflecting on my life. Introspection. Hah, I realize, I'm always doing that. I'm kinda known for it. But I've been a bit more deliberate about it recently. Working out the problems of what, exactly, it is I do not like about my job, the position in my life, etc. And being really self-centered in a way I've never been, never let myself be, before. Not really listening to what other people think, or certainly not nearly as much as I usually have in the past. One of the bigger realizations I've had is about extremes. I kind of gave up on music because I assumed I wouldn't make it professionally (probably rightly so), but I am recognizing that (duh) just because I don't do it professionally does not in any way limit my ability or the need, really, for me to sing and play guitar in my free time; I can even spend money on it. It's still worth it, because it makes me feel that much better. And I don't think I have ever really recognized that. At least not about music. Actually reminds me of Glee from last week, the one with Neal Patrick Harris, who is out to get arts programs because he feels like they lead him on, and made him erroneously believe he could succeed as a star. Anyway, I saw that and kind of recognized my own thought process, obviously a hyperbolistic version, but it helped me recognize how ridiculous what I was thinking was. And I'd been coming to that conclusion already, but it highlighted it.
Friday, May 21, 2010
There's Always Hope, Even When It's Hard to See
Anyhow, it felt like a death march to me. And that was just kind of sad. She told me some more about her life, which was sad. And the actual hearing wasn't so bad--I think she has a shot at keeping the apartment (though I'm really unclear as to how all of these things work). So we were on the train heading back, after she'd been a bit tearful on and off the whole trip, and she says to me, "thank you so much for coming with me, I would have froze up if you hadn't been there." And something about it just made me want to burst into tears. This woman has had such a hard time. And lord knows she's made her own dumb decisions, and I certainly don't think that deserves any kind of free and clear pass, but I think her biggest fault is letting people walk all over her, because she feels so powerless (and has been) to do anything about it. And I just went with her. Not even representing her in any legal way or anything (obviously, as I am not a lawyer), and she was so appreciative of my coming. By making this simple trip, I made her feel special. It just kind of broke my heart. And reminded me what a difference I can make. That part is nice.
After the trip downtown, I went to a meeting for a project I'll be volunteering for that I'm actually pretty psyched about. It's a microfinance consulting company who is doing a research project on illegal Mexican migrants' remittances and how they might be better spent, particularly on insurance (life, health, lost wages due to illness). So we had a fun little brainstorming meeting about the survey we'll be using, and I really got to be quite a huge part of the question development, which is kind of cool. I'm a bit disappointed I won't be able to go to the regular meeting more (since I have to actually "work"), but I'll be able at least to do the surveys on weekends and be sort of in the loop, and they said they may be able to schedule some meetings at times I could actually come. It was so fun to again be working out phrasing of questions, and talking about research questions and how to turn them into questions to really ask people. I missed that. And I get to be sort of the health care/insurance expert. Which is kind of awesome, and I strangely feel like I can totally do that, especially after paying so much attention to the debate over the past year+. It's just exciting to be able to put that into a paper (even if it's just a small part of the background). More later. Sleep now. I am exhausted. Finally I have a weekend to myself--I'm so so so excited to just relax. Just wish it were on my rooftop in Brooklyn....just not yet. But soon!
Monday, March 1, 2010
Sleepless Ranting
This is, in fact, an addendum to my most recent post, The REAL Rules, in which I discuss some of the more ridiculous things people say in online personals. But this is just seriously incredible; awesomely ridiculous. This guy wrote me a nice little message, saying I'd caught his eye and whatever. So I wrote him back requesting that he write a bit more, as his profile essays are blank (this should have been red flag number 1; ignored). I am trying to give people the benefit of the doubt. Evidently this is a mistake. So this dude writes me back a very nice, extensive message that was pretty interesting, mostly grammatically sound, etc etc. He sounded thoughtful, intelligent, and aside from his being born in a certain country that will not be named from which I have known 3 men, 2 of whom ripped my heart to shreds, there seemed to be no more red flags. Until at the very end of this long and decent message falls this line:
oh and i have to say it makes me a little nervous that you work with HIV patients, does it make me a bad person? i think my preoccupation is reasonable.
- Not sure I would consider entering into a sexual relationship with someone so incredibly uninformed about how STIs are transmitted.
- Actually, I work with HIV positive patients because I am HIV positive...JK, but that sinking, disgusted feeling you just got? Yeah, that's why I'd never date you.
- Um, well considering that I neither share needles nor have unprotected sex with anyone, much less my patients, my risk of contracting HIV is pretty low.
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
The REAL Rules
Anyway, none of this is the point and I'm getting really rant-y (excited about my interview tomorrow!!!). I just came across a profile one one of said dating websites where someone posted a picture with the caption, "Me and my girlfriend in 2006." Now, it's fine that you had a girlfriend in 2006. But let's be serious, rule number 1 of dating websites is NOT to post pictures of you with a girlfriend. That's just stupid. Right? I kind of can't believe it. But it also made me think about some of the other weird things people have said in their profiles/messages to me. The other day, I received a message entitled "I'm confused..." and containing the message "are you shy or something?" I have no idea WTF this guy was talking about. I think I'm pretty upbeat/open/not shy in my profile essays. And pictures. It's weird. And then this other guy recently sent me a message entitled "Hi":
hey whats up my name is [insert name] im 26 just got out the military looking for cool new friends i believe everything starts with a friendship. I seen ur profile i think ur a fun outgoing person and would like to get to know you better i love to dance and enjoy the outdoors what are some things you like to do for fun ?well hope to here from you bye P.S cute pics whats ur nationality?
Seriously?? I mean, I admit it's kinda sweet, but PROOFREAD, people! It's like a 6 year old could have written this. And his profile was lots of caps (though not entirely, which is just...weirder) and similarly mis-spelled (I have this special place on my hate list for "u" instead of "you" or "ur" instead of "your" or "you're." Additionally, this young man is unfamiliar with correct conjugation, and likes to point out the obvious--"I seen ur profile" is the most offensive line to me. Of course you HAVE seen my profile. Also can you not add two letters to "ur" to make it correct?? Is it that much trouble? Maybe some periods and capitalization while you're at it. The nationality think is kind of a cool question, but I said I was white...I'm just kind of wondering what nationality he suspects I am, and also if he knows the definition of nationality, instead of perhaps heritage. But I'll let that one slide). Also, we're 33% of a match, based on how we've answered a bunch of questions about what we want in relationships and our values. What makes you think I would like you, or even respond?? Just as that dude who wrote me the previous message, I'm confused.
I could go on about the 20 or so guys I've met in person, too, but overall, they were not so bad, there was just no connection. Or they seemed...scared? of me.
I will say, on the plus side, I've gotten to meet lots of people who are in their own ways, quite interesting and as I said, I never would have met. Maybe for the best, but I think it's been a good way to spend some time. And I don't actually feel like my online dating luck has been any worse than my in-life dating luck. In fact, I think in some ways it's been more worthwhile. In real life, I've had some weird dating shit happen to me as well. I guess my point in all of this is to give a shout-out to internet dating. At some point, I'll probably write a bit more. As for now, I just wanted to mostly share about that guy and his girlfriend picture, just as an example of how naive people can be about what "works," just in life in general. I'm consistently astonished at peoples' idiocy. But whatever. I'm learning to deal.
Monday, February 15, 2010
This Progress
"The End of the Weekend" by Anthony Hecht This is a poem that my High School Senior English teacher gave us to read. The whole year was actually pretty influential for me in terms of actually appreciating literature, but this poem has stuck with me, even nearly six years later. I'm not sure exactly what it was about the poem--it's a fairly simple poem. I think it really was the way my teacher had us examine the symbolism. I suppose I should explain that until this point, I was extremely cynical about interpretation in literature or poetry, I just thought people wrote things and that it was sort of bullshit to read into them. But this poem is beautiful and haunting, both in its surface reading, and also when it is dissected a bit. The words Hecht chooses are clearly well-thought out. Intentional. For the first time in my life, I began to believe that some symbolism was truly intentional and thought-out. I realized that more than anything, the reason I did not believe this about poetry previously was because I hadn't had the right coaching, and wasn't reading the right poems. And I still think a lot of reading into things is useless. But this was step one in appreciating those that are really meant to be pulled apart, enjoyed like a some kind of very messy, juicy fruit instead of sterile in a glass.
Singer by Jump, Little Children This I can't link to, but if you want to listen to, I'd be happy to share my music directly. Just ask. This song is amazing. Raw, beautiful, sexy, dark. Jump, Little Children, for those who know me well, is a group who I feel sort of defines who I am. If you like their music, I'll probably like you. At least kind of. But this song, more than any of the others, I find enchanting. It's really sad, and about impermanence, more than anything. Living in the moment. And while their music and concerts have filled a part of my emotional life that have inspired me to liken them to "my religion" on many occasions, this song is one meant to be listened to, felt. Meant to be present to. Their other music can be background music, but Singer is an experience. The last line is "This song will be over and so will you and me/this song will be over and so will you and me/this song--" and then the music just ends. Powerful.
Tristes Tropiques by Claude Levi-Strauss I read this book as a part of a class Senior year of undergrad called Rituals and Rhetoric by the previous dean of the Religious Studies Department, who was a funny and delightful gentleman, Ruel Tyson. Like that English class in high school with the End of the Weekend, I do give quite a bit of credit to the manner in which this incredible book was taught. Still, it was an experience to read this book, much unlike any other I've had reading a book. It's basically about Claude Levi-Strauss, one of the pioneering anthropologists in the Twentieth Century, and his journey to Brazil, the Caribbean and India. But it is not primarily about the places, but his internal struggle over how to be an anthropologist, and what that means. He was way before his time in terms of thinking of culture as a construct, not something definitive. And part of what struck me about the book (which I don't even think I've read all of--we just read excerpts for class) was how it defied categorization. Though it is "about" his travels, there is an entire chapter about the difficulty of capturing a sunset, which serves as a fantastic metaphor for anthropology. I still intend to read the whole thing from start to finish, but even having only read what I have, it just struck me as so true.
And now we have come to my most recent brilliant discovery. Tino Sehgal. I've read a few of the articles about his philosophy on art since going to the exhibit. Basically, he feels like there's enough stuff in the world, and he wants to create things that are impermanent. Which is, more than anything, honest. The reality is, going to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and looking at the pots and statues and rugs and etcetera is only seeing it in its context, at the time. The color is maybe a little different than when people were actually using these items. Paintings are different when they are all together. Context and time are inescapable. Sehgal just admits that, and doesn't try to run away from it, even embracing it. Some of it is that experiencing the exhibit kind of caught me off guard. I was going like I went to the Tim Burton exhibit at MoMA (which is cool, just not mind-blowing or even really particularly thought-provoking).
What these things have in common is, I think, pushing me to realize the capabilities of each medium--poetry, songs, books, art. They are all capable of achieving this connection, this rare moment of truth. And I have seen so many other poems, songs, books or art exhibits that have been cool, interesting, maybe even made me think a bit. But these are the ones that stick with me. The ones where I feel a real connection with the person who created each piece of art, like I'm somehow seeing into their souls, just for a moment. And one thing said in one of the articles by Sehgal about what his point was, more or less, is taking a world that is full of STUFF, which is what artwork generally is, and bringing it back to being about relationships.
Real, raw, haunting, inescapable, enchanting truth.
Making Art Out of An Encounter [New York Times]
You Can't Hold It, But You Can Own It [New York Times]
In the Naked Museum: Talking, Thinking, Encountering [New York Times]
Art World Drama! Tino Sehgal Calls the New York Times "Crass" [W Magazine]
Tino Sehgal [W Magazine]
How I Made an Artwork Cry [New York Magazine]
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
Poverty
I am surrounded by poverty. The neighborhood I live in is full of undocumented residents who do not speak English. The assumption in my neighborhood is that you speak Spanish, and many stores don't even bother to hire workers who are bilingual, because everyone speaks Spanish. It's convinient that I do, but even I have had some difficulties.
I can't tell if some of my feeling isolated from coworkers and patients is my age--I'm definitely younger than many of them, but even those my age don't get technology the way I do--a supervisor made a comment about how "this genration" just grew up with technology and therefore understands it, but I really don't think it's quite that simple. There are folks who are older than I am who truly "get" technology, and kids my age (young "adults") who do NOT understand it. I think it has more to do with how your brain works and your socioeconomic class. But that's just me. Maybe. But the isolation part is getting a little better. Bit by bit.
Friday, January 8, 2010
Motto of the Decade
Sunday, December 27, 2009
A Trip Home
I've been doing lots of thinking, about the future, what I want out of life, what's important to me, etc. I finally realized I just don't want to long-term be away from family, and all of the lovely people of Chapel Hill, and that maybe if I have a reason to move away, I should, but if I don't, it's a good place to be.
I'm slowly getting excited about going to Vienna (cautiously), but considering all of the things I need to begin doing to be ready to go--all the stuff I need to get rid of and paperwork I'll have to do. But it will be great to have some time in Chapel Hill before I leave, and then I do think it will be an incredible experience. And then I can come back, if I want to.
Considering what I've gravitated toward at all of my jobs (databases), I'm thinking of going into Information Sciences. I think it's appropriately a combination of person-to-person contact and task-oriented, which I've found are both important to me. And there's actually a Master degree I can get (who knew?!) AND UNC has the #1 program in country. So there. It definitely isn't something I'd really thought of before, but my dad suggested it and the more I've thought about it, the more appropriate it seems, and the more I like the idea. So perhaps Vienna, applying for Information Science grad school, moving back to Chapel Hill for a few month before starting grad school. Hopefully working. I've got a plan. :-)
The Princess and the Frog Review
Tiana is the main character. A lot of focus has been put on her race (she's black, if you hadn't heard), but the film doesn't outright address this, which I actually think is quite progressive. She is clearly lower class, and it is evident that her neighborhood is black and poor; the family her mother sews fo is white and rich. But there are others who are both white and black who populate the New Orleans landscape and who are not obviously poor nor rich, which I think is somewhat accurate/realistic. So race-wise, I actually found it appropriate (it is set in the past). Also, the father of Charlotte, the rich white girl for whom Tiana's mother sews sparkly princess dresses, is respectful towards Tiana's mother. I also like that Charlotte, despite being white and rich, while sometimes oblivious to the woes of Tiana's life, is at her core supportive and not out to get her--she is a decent person, unlike, say, the evil stepsisters in Cinderella. So in terms of how the film portrays and deals with both class and race, I actually am quite impressed.
The main relationship, between Tiana and Prince Naveen, is one that is both inter-racial and inter-cultural (he's the prince of Macedavia or something?), which isn't even spoken addressed as a problem to deal with. Prince Naveen is also a potential suitor for Charlotte, which is interesting--that this man of unidentified race could marry either a black or white woman I think is great.
In terms of strong female leads, I definitely think this film ranks #1 of Disney films. Tiana is sure of herself, has dreams that she's working hard to fulfill (and which she was encouraged to work hard to obtain by her father), but still is open to romance. I love all of this. There's also a point when Prince Naveen realizes he loves Tiana but he is willing to let her go if he can help her acheive her dream of opening a resaurant. Brilliant! I actually think this is my favorite component of the movie, precisely because the biggest issue I had with a story like the Little Mermaid is that Ariel had to give up her voice, family and species to fulfill her romantic destiny, which is just disturbing. Tiana gets a man who supports her in getting what she wants.
I am really relieved by seeing the movie--it gives me hope for this generation of young people both in terms of race/class and also romantic relationships, and I am delighted to have a fun children's movie that I wouldn't feel bad about showing my kids, with a message that luck and hard work are what it takes to get ahead in life. So, I find myself saying, well done, Disney. I admit I'm a little surprised. But pleasantly.
Saturday, October 10, 2009
Saturday.
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Feelin' Preachy
I've been contemplating, discussing, reading; I had a lively conversation with Palmer (roommate) yesterday evening about justice (again); he feels quite similarly to Hans (maybe it's a gendered thing?? Guys are more into retribution?), and particularly is into the idea of personal responsibility and the belief that we make our own choices about life consciously (ie, the woman on the corner who is on drugs and effed up her life had just as much opportunity *NOT* to do crack when when she started as he or I did; we made different choices and therefore we should't have to pay for her unfortunate ones). Obviously, I have the same issues with Palmer's argument as I did with that of Hans. No matter what the argument is about it being right or wrong to help others who have made unfortunate life decisions for whatever reasons, the bottom line for me is essentially a pragmatic one--a person who is on crack and bumming cigarettes/subway rides all the time is not an asset to our community/country; helping this woman allows her to contribute in a way that will be quite advantageous to us all, as a whole. Our society suffers from the loss of the skills/abilities/thoughts/revelations of people who have been disadvantaged to the point of being unable to realize their potential up to this point. We look at these people as liabilities instead of seeing them for what they are--assets. We refuse to invest in them because we do not believe in them. But the real losers in that situation are us, society. We lose out on the productivity of millions because they are incarcerated, by prisons or drugs or poverty, when we absolutely need their insight into solving the problems we face. We refuse to accept them as legitimate members and contributors to our society simply because they were handed the shit end of the stick.
I think truly part of what this comes down to is whether or not you believe people are innately good or evil and whether or not you think people can be "fixed" or rehabilitated. I believe people are a product of their culture, environment, etc. While we all make our own decisions, they are highly contextualized--based upon what options we see, not necessarily what options actually exist; as well as how we see ourselves and what decisions we "should" or "would" make, given who we "are." A personal example of this is of how I see myself as someone who gets a post-graduate degree. I believe, with all my heart and soul for oh so many reasons (how I was raised, the way I think, my own skills/what I see as my skills and abilities, etc etc) that I will go to graduate school at some point. So much so that in effect, in the way that I see myself, I already have that degree. That may sound strange, but I've thought about it quite a bit in the past couple years. Ever since the end of my Freshman year in college, I knew that I would eventually go on to get at least a master's degree in something. There is no question for me, short of my life ending prematurely. It is already a part of who I am to myself, if that makes sense. I wholly believe this influences how I conduct myself with others, what books I choose to read, the image I project of myself/my confidence in who I am, etc. It requires me to believe that I am able--financially and academically--to obtain a degree. It requires that I see things in a bigger-picture sort of way. I have an idea of what it means to have a master's degree--who that person is. And while I do not particularly judge others based upon their degree(s), and I do not think that getting a higher degree will make me a better person than anyone else, I do feel (not think, but on a baser level, feel) that it is an essential part of who I am. I hope I have managed to explain this marginally well. My point is, we are a product of our environments, and that that includes not just externally what happens around us, but how we interpret others' view of us, and how that informs our own view of ourself. That view, in turn, I believe highly influences what we believe we are capable of and therefore what we are actually, in reality, capable of. I see the view that Hans and Palmer hold (which, by the way, it seems to me is more common/popular than mine) as unwilling to admit a lack of control and autonomy in our own lives--my belief requires an understanding and admittance of influence from the outside world to a degree that I do not believe Palmer nor Hans are comfortable with. It's scary to think that where you are is circumstantial, because then you could be that woman. Which is my whole point--we must have empathy with people like that, we must not distance ourselves so as to feel comfortable. That discomfort is required for us to be moral and ethical in our politics and values.
This ties interestingly into a fascinatingly wonderful book I'm reading, The Wimp Factor: Gender Gaps, Holy Wars, & the Politics of Anxious Masculinity by Stephen J. Ducat. I have just begun this book and yet! It is one of the most fascinating books I've read in a long time. Ducat has a keen sense for the root of conservatism being hyper-masculinity and femiphobia (a word he uses a lot and I love). I very much appreciate his connecting the personal and political, specifically for men. And although he hasn't gotten much into why women might be conservative (which is a question that endlessly plagues me, although I suppose some other authors have attempted to answer that question), it is really nifty to see such a strong connection between femiphobia and some of the particular policies of the extreme right. Keeping in mind that I've read less than a chapter of the book, so far he argues that men are afraid of being female, and that their views on everything from homosexuality to welfare are influenced by the desire to be masculine and phallic. The argument ties very neatly into the research I did on domestic violence in Mexico (unfortunately I don't have access to the studies I looked at at the moment...I'll see if I can find and post them; in the meantime, you'll just have to trust me) that showed that women in less traditional/more financially egalitarian marriages/partnerships had a higher incidence of domestic violence. This is postulated to be because their husbands feel threatened by their wives power; they must regain their "place" as men and one way to assert that is through violence. When I first found this study, I was shocked. It was totally counterintuitive to me until I read the theory behind why it is and then it just clicked--I also began to think of domestic violence--and consequently rape/oppression of women--not as something men impose on women but rather a societal structure that men suffer from as well. If they are so intimidated, scared and unable to prove their masculinity that they must literally exert physical pain upon another living human, that is sad. They feel so powerless that they must take power away from someone else. Now, I'm not defending domestic violence or rape in any way--but if this is what is causing those things, I do believe it is important to understand the underlying mechanisms of violence perpetuated by men. And while there are always exceptions, I do believe that the vast majority of violence committed by men is due to this feeling of powerlessness, in some capacity or another. So there you go. We must redefine masculinity and allow men to be their authentic selves and define themselves based upon who they are as individuals as opposed to how their gender or sex as defined by society tells them to be. A good lesson, I think, for us all.
Friday, September 11, 2009
Justice As A Concept
Moving on, back to justice. Our conversation about rape diverted towards what to do about it. At this point, I argued that I did not believe in justice (a bit unfair, I know) and that I would prefer to heal all involved (since I believe rape is about power, and that the rapist needs help instead of us looking down on him, or her). Context: Hans is a lawyer. His father is cheif of police. He is a strong proponent of justice.
In a later conversation with a friend of his who is also Swedish (and a lawyer), I realized that perhaps our disagreement had something to do with a difference in our cultural upbringing and more specifically regarding the ideas we have about what justice means and looks like. To me, justice is about vengence. It is about getting even. I don't believe you really CAN "make up" for a crime committed, and moreover, I disagree that punishment deters future criminal acts. I prefer prevention. I generally feel this way, not just about crime, but health and disaster, etc. It is why I so highly value understanding why things happen, what motivates people. Not all things are preventable, but much of the world's "bad stuff" is, I believe. Anyway, Hans argued that you can't just let people get away with things. This, I must say, I do agree with (I think that's with a resounding "duh" also). But I think we should focus on prevention and on understanding why someone committed a crime and what would prevent them from perpetrating another. To me, this is the goal of "punishment". It is not about retribution, beause I don't think retribution is pragmatic. It doesn't make the world a better place. That should be, I believe, the goal of the justice system--to better the world by making changes that cut down on crimes committed.
So those are just some thoughts...btw, I typed this on my phone while waiting "on" line (as they say in New York instead of in line) for my driver's license!
Thursday, September 3, 2009
Let's All Be Human(e)!
I've done a lot of thinking about gender roles, relationships, how we should related to one another; all of that stuff. Firstly, I want to express my outrage at this crazy woman, Kay Hymowitz, who thinks that we should all go back to men and women behaving as though we were trying to win some prize--marriage--instead of just relate and form partnerships with one another. I'm confused by this. I have read He's Just Not That Into You and watched Sex and the City. I think I've experienced a lot of the cultural indoctrination of how relationships are supposed to be; here I'll get a little personal--at the same time, I think my parents are sort of a-typical. My mother does have a bit more of a traditional bent on males than I do. I refuse to believe that men are really all that different than women. Obviously they have different anatomy, different hormones, which change the way they react to things emotionally perhaps, but all-in-all, I think both men and women are capable of being honest, rational, and communicative with each other. I think the Rules are stupid. I also recognize, however, that we are in a transitory phase of gender roles. Things are unclear (all the more reason to be communicative). So sometimes it is nice to just relax and let the typical gender roles drive things. I'm not totally averse to this but I do think it is something we should be aware of when we're doing it. Ok I'm onto analyzing someone else's argument.
Hymowitz wrote a piece previously about the whole concept of the child-man, and how men are putting off serious relationships because they're basically too immature. She got all of these responses and explains:
Their argument, in effect, was that the SYM is putting off traditional markers of adulthood—one wife, two kids, three bathrooms—not because he’s immature but because he’s angry. He’s angry because he thinks that young women are dishonest, self-involved, slutty, manipulative, shallow, controlling, and gold-digging. He’s angry because he thinks that the culture disses all things male. He’s angry because he thinks that marriage these days is a raw deal for men.
So, right off the bat, I'm having issues with these men playing victim and claiming that "young women are dishonest, self-involved, slutty, manipulative, shallow, controlling, and gold-digging." I'm all about re-defining gender roles. I don't think we should "diss" all things male. In fact, I am a huge proponent of men being able to be themselves instead of having to play into ANY stereotype at all. I'll come back to this, because it is basically my problem with all of this--that any general statements can be made at all (that women are slutty, shallow gold-diggers, or that men are lazy, commitment-phobic child-men; either is ridiculous because some women may very well be slutty, shallow gold-diggers, and some men lazy, commitment-phobic child-men, but certainly not all of them) is sort of missing the point of relationships as I see them. To me, a relationship is a very individual thing--it is a partnership, a connected agreement betweent two people, not either person trying to manipulate the other into losing so that they win.
Hymowitz claims that the problem is that men are left wondering "what (or, as they might put it, WTF) women want." Why don't you ask them? That's really all I can say. She claimst that men and women are mysteries to each other and that "one reason people developed so many rules around courtship was that they needed some way to bridge the Great Sexual Divide." I'm so confused by this. Can we not speak to each other? Can we not ask each other what we want? Is our communication so hindered that we must rely upon the "traditional" rules of courtship? At least I agree with her on the point that men are "wooing" women who "are, at least theoretically, their equals—socially, professionally, and sexually." But I do have a problem with the idea of "wooing." Can't women woo men? Isn't that part of the equality? Is there really actually a problem with that? Why do we need the expectations?
Here is the real problem:
But then, when an SYM walks into a bar and sees an attractive woman, it turns out to be nothing like that. The woman may be hoping for a hookup, but she may also be looking for a husband, a co-parent, a sperm donor, a relationship, a threesome, or a temporary place to live. She may want one thing in November and another by Christmas. “I’ve gone through phases in my life where I bounce between serial monogamy, Very Serious Relationships and extremely casual sex,” writes Megan Carpentier on Jezebel, a popular website for young women. “I’ve slept next to guys on the first date, had sex on the first date, allowed no more than a cheek kiss, dispensed with the date-concept altogether after kissing the guy on the way to his car, fucked a couple of close friends and, more rarely, slept with a guy I didn’t care if I ever saw again.” Okay, wonders the ordinary guy with only middling psychic powers, which is it tonight?
This guy doesn't need psychic powers, just those of communication. Ask this woman what she wants. I agree that this is pretty typical--what women want at any one time will vary from woman to woman and from time to time. Is this not also true of men? God forbid women be nuanced and complex human beings with different desires depending upon her position in life, or even how she's feeling that day or week, how her other social connections are at the time. God forbid you have to ASK HER what she wants. That we have to be HONEST with each other about what we're looking for.
Hymowitz says many women have "personal scripts" that they believe their date must follow. Once again, though there is this issue of communication. Here it's the problem of women having some sort of expectation that she failst to communicate. I, as a human, cannot expect someone to do something so specific as opening a door when I have not expressed that this is important to me. Or at the very least, I do not think I should not fault them for not doing it unless I ask. I also take issue with the fact that people act as though everyone wants the same thing, and you're wrong if you want something and someone doesn't do it. If someone's "idea of a date is that the man plans the evening and takes the woman out" and the guy you go out with doesn't do this, don't go out with him again! Or TELL him that and see how he responds. That will tell you a lot more about him relationally than if he had done what was expected of him from the beginning.
I understand that we have certain social expectations, and when they are changing it is challengeing because we do have to communicate in explicit ways that we are not used to. But I actually think that is a good thing; I think it makes fore a healthier relationship. But what is WRONG with this woman not liking the guy because he didn't open the door for her? If that's what she wants, the guy should find someone who doesn't mind. Because there are plenty of women who do not care. He should be with one of those women. There is often this attitude (take people in the Bachelor/Bachelorette, for example) that you can win anyone over. That just does not make sense to me. While I don't believe there's The One, I believe there are various people who you will work with, but that that number is finite. No one can be a good match for everyone, and we shouldn't expect to be. This is perfectly exemplified in the whole idea of the Game--as in men learning how to pick up any woman he wants because "women want alpha males, the Seduction Community agrees." What??! How is this possibly true for ALL WOMEN?
So since all women want the same things, but it's changing all the time, this is indecisive. Evidently men see women's "indecisiveness" (I would see this a complex, nuanced personality with complex, nuanced desires as a positive thing, but whatever) as just too confusing, frustrating and therefore clearly it is just women being entitled.
Sure, girls can—and do—ask guys out for dinner and pick up the check without missing a beat. But that doesn’t clarify matters, men complain. Women can take a Chinese-menu approach to gender roles. They can be all “Let me pay for the movie tickets” on Friday night and “A single rose? That’s it?” on Valentine’s Day. This isn’t equality, say the male-contents; it’s a ratification of female privilege and, worse, caprice. “Women seemingly have decided that they want it all (and deserve it, too),” Kevin from Ann Arbor writes. “They want to compete equally, and have the privileges of their mother’s generation. They want the executive position, AND the ability to stay home with children and come back into the workplace at or beyond the position at which they left. They want the bad boy and the metrosexual.”
I do not condone women bitching about things that they haven't talked about (the whole "A single rose? That's it?" is a little whiny for my tastes). But wanting to be able to stay home with your kids when they're young and then return to working is not entitled--it's what BOTH men and women should be able to do. I'm not sure about this "bad boy and the metrosexual" stuff, because I think it's weird to have some sort of "type" that you're looking for in the longterm. But I do think it's funny. But women DO deserve it. We all do--men AND women. What these men fail to realize is that the traditional script of relationships fails both men and women. At least that's what I think.
Next, Hymowitz goes on about how women want bad boys. This is just too ridiculous to respond too much to, but here's what I think: men interperet groveling at a women's feet as being a "nice guy." So no, don't worship me--treat me like a person who you respect. And maybe some of us "want" bad boys because we're just so used to being treated as an object--either one men adore or admonish--which makes us expect to be treated that way. I think a lot of guys' ideas of the "nice guy" are actually just the flip side to the "bad boy" coin. Let's treat each other as fellow human beings. I think that will work best.
But this brings Hymowitz to her thesis--that men are forced into a position of becoming a pick-up artist because women are just so confusing, men need to write their own new rules. These rules are based on Darwin--natural selection. And women like alpha men. These men don't have to respect women because they can "get laid anytime [they] want." And now I'm confused because I thought this article was about love. Evidently, men are really uncomplicated--all they want is sex. Hymowitz goes on to talk about this newly developed attitude towards "dating" (I use the term lightly), which I just refuse to go into more in-depth because it is so inhumane.
That is the real problem I have with all of this--as I keep saying, there is a lack of nuance, or recognition that we all need connections to other human beings. Men need them. Women need them. None of us is perfect, but if we were more honest and upfront about things, I think we would be a lot better off. This is the easy way out--to just look for sex, to treat the other gender as a commodity to be "had" instead of people to relate to. But we lose so much when we fail to recognize and comfort other's vulnerabilities, as well as share our own.
Thank god there are men like Will Wilkinson. His response argues that
annoyances and disappointments suffered in the process of realizing fundamental conditions of a decent society don’t call into question the desirability of those conditions. All this vexation is a very, very small price to pay for equality. For men, it is a very, very small price to pay for the opportunity to share a life with a peer, a full partner, rather than with a woman limited by convention and straitened opportunity to a more circumscribed and subordinate role in life. Sexual equality has created the possibility of greater exactness and complementarity in matching women to men. That is, in my book, a huge gain to men. But equality does raise expectations for love and marriage. The prospect of finding a true partner, rather than someone to satisfactorily perform the generic role of husband or wife, leaves many of us single and searching for a good long time. But this isn’t about delaying adulthood, it’s about meeting higher standards for what marriage and family should be.
That is what I thought! And he rightly points out that "many men aren’t angry and confused because they don’t know what women want. They’re angry because they want what their fathers or grandfathers had, and they can’t get it. They’re confused because they can’t quite grasp why not." I also appreciate that Wilkinson recognizes gay culture as a place to look for some guidance because it offers "a wide variety of templates for manhood that are at once unmistakably masculine, playfully ironic, aesthetic, emotionally open, and happily sexual." I have found this as well, as a heterosexual female. But for real--it'd be great if we could all just be human beings, treating each other as equal people. Really, isn't that what relationships are all about?
Love in the Time of Darwinism [City Journal]
The "Menaissance" and Its Dickscontents [Will Wilkinson]
Is There Anything Good About Men? [American Psychological Association Presentation]
Monday, August 31, 2009
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
More on Relationships
I have been thinking a lot about this whole idea of poly relationships and this just takes the cake for me. Let me be clear--I am not sure personally what I feel about this. But I certainly thing it is interesting to think about, especially considering a very interesting Modern Love article from the NYTimes a bit ago. I was blown away by this intellectual and measured reaction to a woman's husband saying he didn't want to be with her any longer and that he didn't love her anymore. Her reaction (in short) is that she doesn't believe him and she tells him he has his shit to deal with, she expects him to deal with it and that's that. I read this and think, "who says women are emotional??" But really, I think this is more how women are naturally, that is, without social conditioning to be concerned about other constantly. So, looking at this in combination with what these women say about nonmonogomous relationships being about being your autonomous self, I see a very strong connection. I think people do often get very wrapped up in their own idea of how connected they should be in their relationship and fail to recognize their own part in their individual growth. Your growth as a person does not stop simply because you are in a relationship...! But I think a lot of people sort of give up, or start to believe that their relationship to some degree takes the place of the necesisity of their own personal growth. Anyway, I just think this is fascinating, connecting feminism, not owning/posessing other people, letting partner(s) have their own autonomy and giving them space to deal with their issues within the relationship...and then you add children in and assuming you are in a stable situation with a relationship or several relationships, I think that could actually be a fairly healthy way to grow up. Obviously bizarre for the "norm," but a village raising a child, and true free love. And I think the Modern Love article is an excellent example of the advantages of nonmonogomous relationships being taken into a monogomous relationship, showing that it is not, in fact, about mongomy versus nonmonogomy, but actually about communication and preserving your individual integrity.
Readings (in Jezebel form):
Is Nonmonogomy A Feminist Relationship Choice? [Jezebel]
Nonmonogomy and Feminism: A Happy Couple [Feministe]
Another Perspective in Nonmonogamy [Feministe]
Those Aren't Fighting Words, Dear [NY Times]
